Yesterday there have been riots in Hungary because their leader admitted that he has been lying about the economy there. I have to say this make me really angry, because the leader of a country should be as competent, intelligent and honest as possible. Indeed a leader of a country has so much responsibility that he should be almost be perfect. Well, how many such people exist that are near perfect? And what are the chances that they are our president? The chances are near zero. That’s why I strongly dislike the concept of leadership. There are many examples in history where leaders have made the lives of many a misery. That’s because it’s completely mad to give so much power to a single person or even a small group. Also make no mistake, in today’s world the margin of error is getting smaller and smaller. We have weapons to end human life on this planet several times over. That means we have to change how we make political decisions, we need to evolve democracy. Software is getting smarter, every year our industry produces computer which are faster. On the other hand democracy didn’t evolve much.
The idea that we vote for people we hardly know is absurd. So what would the political process in an ideal world be? Ideally the smartest, the most competent people would make the political decisions. In other words political power should be given according to competence, not according to the ability to sell oneself successfully and to give speeches.
So instead of voting every few years we should find the most competent people for each political decision. For instance if we would like to make a decision concerning how our hospitals work then those people who actually work in that field like nurses and doctors should be given more political power to help make a decision in that field. Want to invade a country? How much do you know about history of that country? Have you lived there? How much do you know about changing a political system successfully through war?
Every person should make a case for themselves why they feel they are competent in this particular decision and they should get judged by a “political jury”. The jurors would be made up from members of the public and their task would be to find out how competent somebody is for a particular political decision. Of course this system isn’t foolproof, but because in every decision many people would be involved it makes sure we come to the right political decision - even if some people have been misjudged.
The current system is a bit like communism, where everybody gets the same of something, in this case voting power. Unfortunately like communism this democratic process doesn’t work very well. People who prefer to read the “The Economist” instead of watching “American Idol” should be rewarded with more political power. Ticking a box every few years is not really what democracy is about, at best its a very primitive form of democracy. Becoming a politician shouldn’t be the only way to make political decisions.
With todays “collaborative software” we could easily set up a system which would produce much better political decisions than the current system. For instance Wikipedia is an example of such a software.
The key for a better world is a smarter political process, and I would even go so far as to say that our survival depends on it. Think about it, modern man exists only for a very short time, and we’ve already had large scale wars which killed millions of people, we’ve already destroyed large portions of this planet through pollution, and the western world is living an unsustainable life style. We wouldn’t be where we are if we had made different decisions in the past. Which basically means the current political systems don’t really work very well and need to evolve.
The problem is that the people in power are happy that they are in power, and they won’t change the system to get themselves out of power. That’s why democracy doesn’t evolve much. So we need to put pressure on politicians to change the system.
If you like this idea you can help spread it by blogging about it, linking to this blog entry, discussing it with family and friends, etc. Also you can find more information about similar ideas by searching for Microdemocracy or E-Democracy on Google.